“Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail.”
Ralph Waldo Emerson
As a modern Eclectic Pagan, Ralph Waldo Emerson has had huge a huge impact on me spiritually. Emerson’s pantheism and belief that all, regardless of belief and practice, have access to what he called the Over-Soul who was for him the best way to describe the reality of Immanent Deity formed, forms me, an intuitive comprehension of Deity that makes sense. He believed, as I do, that we are all ultimately of one substance, sharing in one Spiritual Reality that merely takes cultural masks so that we may more easily experience it. I would later learn that this realization is the heart of all mysticism. For Emerson, the mystic was someone who was a master of will and choice and one who saw the moral truth behind appearances, getting this awareness not primarily from intellectualism but from the immanent reality of their own experience. This experience flows naturally from the mystic’s own spiritual awakening. As someone who has frequently been the recipient of both paranormal and spiritual experiences and as someone who could rarely, if ever, take anything on faith so long as there was a path to available validating experience. Emerson’s point of view has always resonated very powerfully with me and still does. Since first reading Emerson long ago, the factors influencing my practices and beliefs have become far more diverse, but I have never lost sight of either the simplicity or elegance of Emerson’s spiritual worldview.
Within the last few weeks the blogosphere has been a bit of a buzz regarding the relative merits of traditionalism vs. those of “making things up.” Ian Corrigan, through his blog Into the Mound has been doing a unique spiritual working that involved calling forth the Court of Brigid a distinctly Celtic Pagan rite of spirit art of a kind that I have never seen in Pagan magick before. This working caused another magickal blog personality Rufus Opus to offer up his somewhat controversial opinion, an opinion that seemed to both reject and envy Ian’s work at the same time. Then Jason Miller (indomandium) added his opinion to the mix, an opinion that was somewhat more reasonable than R.O.’s opinion.
Over the last few years, I have noticed a, in my opinion, ridiculous and unnecessary schism between Magickal Traditionalists and Magickal Eclectics. I was a solitary practitioner of witchcraft/magick and so was nearly everyone else I knew and before the rise of social networking and blogging I never noticed that such a schism even existed. I had totally avoided Myspace while it was in its heyday because, rightly or wrongly, I saw it as a titanic waste of time. I largely avoided Facebook as a waste of time as well until maybe two years ago when I broke down and, at the request of a friend who wanted a way to keep in touch with me, created a Facebook page.
Well, I am happy to acknowledge that I was wrong. Facebook, like any other tool, is only as good or as bad as how you use it. As soon as I got comfortable with Facebook I quickly made a point of networking within the Pagan and Magickal Community. I was rewarded by being exposed to ideas, practices and inspiration that I had never encountered before along with colorful and engaging individuals whose presence I came to value. Unfortunately, this cornucopia of knowledge, inspiration and communication was joined with a concurrent ugliness and pettiness of human egotism as I quickly found myself surrounded by folks obsessed with their practice being the “One True Way” who judged others were “fluffy” and ignorant of real Paganism and magick. Ironically, I was nearly universally unimpressed by the levels of either knowledge or wisdom possessed by those busily mocking others unlike themselves. To note, I claim no vastly enlightened or peculiarly insightful understanding of magick, the occult or witchcraft (…well maybe a little bit) but still I remain unimpressed.
Fortunately in the aggregate my experience of Facebook has been far more positive than negative but I have to admit that if I was a younger man, less confident in my beliefs and practice, this onslaught may have turned me from the Pagan and Magickal Community altogther. In any case there have been plenty of times where I was, and sometimes still am, left staring at shaking my head at the arrogance I see expressed by some at those who do not share their point of view.
Pondering the schism between Traditionalists and Eclectics I am forced to quote Thomas Paine when he said, “The mind once enlightened cannot again become dark.”
One cannot be exposed to great wisdom of traditions outside one’s own and not be changed from that exposure. Allow me to state categorically before I continue , that true traditionalists, those who seek to reconnect us with our ancestral pasts lost due to the onslaught of Christianity have my deepest respect. By seeking threads of continuity, Traditionalists do the Pagan community as a whole a great service.
However, just as some Eclectic Pagans are nearly whimsical in their choices, some Traditionalists are hidebound, rejecting out of hand anything that wasn’t practiced by their ancestors. Both are, in my opinion, missing out.
I personally couldn’t be anything other than an Eclectic Pagan because I have found that once one sets foot upon the road of studying comparative mythology, world religions and their wisdom, and the various mystical practices of the world’s great religious and spiritual traditions one begins to see things differently. One is forced to face and attempt to integrate different spiritual paradigms. How does one come to terms with the differences between the Hindu Chakras and the Taoist Elixir Fields? How does one integrate philosophical Monism with the Buddhist conception of Dependent Origination? How does one square Panentheism with Polytheism? Is there a way of integrating the reciprocal relationships our ancestors had with the gods and the ‘pure religion’ of devotion seen in monotheistic mysticism? What portions of what you’ve learned is relevant to your belief system and spiritual practice and what is not?

Candy can be great.......but it can also rot out all of your teeth and cause you to gain 100 pounds.
All these questions can be answered via study, contemplation, meditation, inspiration, experience and intuition. There are no hard and fast answers. No one is going to tell you that you are correct or incorrect. The surety of faith found in traditionalists who have teachings handed down for centuries or millennia is not something that Eclectic Pagans have. The awareness we possess comes not from the security of structure but from the fluidity of experience. This fluidity is freedom.
We have freedom to explore, to seek, to know and to experience well beyond the boundaries of those who cling to any single set of doctrines or dogmas. We are free to blaze new spiritual trails and be inspired in new and wonderful ways. We also have the freedom to fail to be accountable, to drift aimlessly, to allow ourselves to wander down blind alleys leading nowhere and to wind up as “jacks of all trades while being masters of none.” So no, Eclectic Paganism isn’t all wine and roses.
Eclectic Paganism is a tough road for the serious practitioner and she will have to develop three core skills without which she will not make any discernable progress despite what seems to be years of practice.
The first quality is discipline. Discipline is a quality of strength and determination that allows one to drive through the arid moments of one’s practice which will come. One certainty in any type of spiritual practice is that there will be times when you no longer find joy in your practice and that the gods seem distant. The world’s great mystics have experienced moments of spiritual aridity so, unless you are suffering from a profound entitlement complex, you must accept that you will as well. At such times I recommend seeing these periods of dryness as tests. Press on, all the while offering up your experiences, hopes, fears, and doubts to your gods. In time this time of testing will pass and you will be rewarded with new levels of awareness, peace and trust in yourself, the gods and your path.
The second quality I recommend the Eclectic Pagan develop is intuition. By intuition I am not referring to psychic intuition but instead the intuition of an adaptive unconscious mind that, upon receiving new information, organizes and integrates that information allowing the Eclectic Pagan to experience true ‘eureka’ moments of true inspiration based on a wealth of experience and study. This type of intuition allows one to develop truly unique insights based on previously absorbed information from potentially countless sources. The only way to feed the intuition of the adaptive unconscious is to study and practice, study and practice, study and practice. There are no shortcuts. If you do this, you will be rewarded with stunning magickal and spiritual insights that will guide you in ways that no external teacher, no matter how well meaning or wise, ever could.
The third necessary quality that must be developed is spiritual discernment. Spiritual discernment relies heavily upon one’s intuition and is what I like to call one’s “Spiritual Bullshit Detector” or (SPD). Your (SPD) is an internal protective mechanism that too is based on consistent study. To develop your (SPD) study comparative mythology, comparative religion and the universality of mystical experience. There is a thread of commonality that weaves its way through the worlds spiritual traditions. Of course there are differences between the world’s spiritual traditions and their mythologies but they are often different cultural masks as opposed to intrinsic differences. The works of Joseph Campbell and Carl Jung are invaluable in seeing through the cultural costumes worn by various myths and getting to the heart of their meaning…which tends to be universal spiritual truths and/or profound truths of the human condition. In combining this kind of study with the work you are doing within the, even loose, system you have chosen you will find that you will be sufficiently grounded enough to prevent a charlatan (whether New Age or Old School) from taking advantage of you. Like the skill of a cultivated intuition, the skill of discernment is more an art than a science. However, despite that, your sense of well-developed intuition and spiritual discernment are your best defenses, as an Eclectic Pagan, against being taken advantage of or being deceived.
Don’t allow anyone to claim that your path as an Eclectic Pagan is somehow invalid. Ultimately for all of us, whether Eclectic or Traditional, the truth of our spirituality is in the sense of fulfillment, wisdom, understanding, compassion, connection and success it offers us and not the superficial criticisms of others. It has been said that the success of a recipe is in the tasting. The success of your Eclectic Pagan spirituality is in the depth of your relationship with your chosen gods or spirits and ultimately it is only your opinion and their opinions that matter.
Tags: discipline, Eclectic Paganism, Emerson, freedom, intuition, spiritual discernment, Spiritual Traditions

























